September 5, 2024

Scaling Up: Key learnings from Germany’s wind and solar integration

Cyber frauds

In 2023, Germany achieved a significant milestone in its energy transition journey, with renewable energy sources accounting for 59.7 per cent of the country’s net public electricity generation. This shift towards greener energy, while commendable, brought about challenges such as negative electricity prices. Meanwhile, India’s renewable energy ambitions are set to revolutionise its energy landscape, aiming to add 500 GW of renewable capacity by 2030. This includes 270-290 GW of solar power and 120-140 GW of wind power, as well as significant contributions from hydro and storage solutions. Germany’s recent experiences with its solar power surplus and resulting negative electricity prices can offer valuable insights into potential economic and grid management challenges and opportunities for India.

Renewable energy contributions

Germany’s substantial investment in solar power has led to a scenario where supply frequently exceeds demand, particularly during sunny periods. This oversupply has resulted in negative electricity prices, meaning that producers pay consumers to use electricity during peak generation times. This underscores the need for effective grid management and energy storage solutions to balance supply and demand. For instance, in early 2024, industrial electricity prices in Germany dropped by almost 23 per cent compared to the previous year due to increased renewable energy integration. Such outcomes highlight both the potential benefits and challenges of scaling renewable energy. Germany’s renewable energy landscape in 2023 saw wind power as the largest contributor, followed by solar power. Wind energy, particularly from onshore turbines, accounted for 31.1 per cent of the total electricity generation. Solar energy contributed 12.1 per cent, maintaining similar levels to the previous year, according to Bundesnetzagentur and Fraunhofer ISE. Biomass and other renewable sources made up the remaining portion. The increase in renewable energy generation was substantial. Wind power generation grew by 18 per cent, reaching 118.7 TWh for onshore and slightly decreasing to 23.5 TWh for offshore, according to Fraunhofer ISE. Solar power generated around 55.2 TWh, almost identical to the previous year. This consistent growth in renewables, coupled with favourable weather conditions, often led to periods where electricity supply exceeded demand.

Negative electricity prices

Negative electricity prices occur when the supply of electricity surpasses the demand, leading to situations where producers have to pay consumers to take excess electricity off the grid. In 2022, Germany experienced 69 hours of negative prices, doubling to 139 hours in 2023, according to EnergyTransition.org and Bundesnetzagentur.

Several factors contribute to negative electricity prices:

  • Wind and solar power generation depend on weather conditions, leading to fluctuating outputs. During periods of high wind and sunny days, the electricity generated can exceed consumption, especially when demand is low, such as on holidays or weekends.
  • Coal and nuclear plants are less flexible in adjusting their output quickly. These plants cannot easily ramp down production during periods of high renewable output, leading to oversupply (EnergyTransition.org) (Fraunhofer ISE).
  • While Germany has invested in energy storage, the capacity is not yet sufficient to store all excess renewable energy. This limits the ability to balance supply and demand effectively (Bundesnetzagentur). Despite the high renewable energy generation, Germany’s energy storage capacity has not kept pace. The country has approximately 40 GWh of installed energy storage capacity, which includes pumped hydro storage, battery storage and other technologies, according to Ember. However, this capacity is insufficient to fully balance the intermittent nature of renewable energy generation. Germany’s energy storage needs are estimated to be significantly higher to stabilise the grid and avoid situations where excess renewable energy leads to negative electricity prices. Estimates suggest that Germany will require approximately 120-150 GWh of energy storage capacity by 2030 to manage the increased renewable energy generation effectively.

Scenario for India

According to Crisil, India’s plan to add 270-290 GW of solar and 120-140 GW of wind power by 2030 could lead to similar situations if not managed effectively. The following are the key challenges and strategies:

  • The rapid expansion of renewable energy in Germany has led to significant changes in electricity pricing dynamics. Negative prices during periods of high solar generation benefit consumers but challenge the profitability of producers. For India, similar trends could emerge, leading to lower electricity costs for industries and consumers and fostering economic growth. However, managing these dynamics requires careful policy planning to avoid potential market disruptions.
  • Integrating large-scale solar and wind power into the grid presents substantial challenges. Advanced forecasting technologies and real-time grid management systems are essential to handle the variability and intermittency of renewable sources. India’s grid infrastructure must be upgraded to accommodate high penetration levels of renewables, ensuring a reliable electricity supply and preventing blackouts.
  • Energy storage is a critical component of managing renewable energy. Germany’s experience highlights the importance of having adequate storage capacity to store excess energy generated during peak production times and release it when production is low. For India, achieving up to 70 GWh of storage will be vital. This includes battery storage, pumped hydro storage and other technologies that can provide the necessary flexibility and stability to the grid. As of 2023, India has a relatively small energy storage capacity compared to its renewable energy generation targets. The country currently has around 5-6 GWh of installed energy storage capacity, primarily in the form of pumped hydro storage and emerging battery storage projects (Bundesnetzagentur) (Ember).

Germany’s experience with negative electricity prices offers valuable lessons for countries like India that are rapidly expanding their renewable energy capacity. Effective grid management, investment in storage technologies and dynamic pricing models are essential strategies to ensure a stable and economically viable energy transition. By learning from Germany’s challenges and successes, India can better navigate its path towards a sustainable energy future. To effectively manage the rapid scaling of solar and wind power, India must implement several key policies:

  • Introducing flexible pricing mechanisms to help balance supply and demand, preventing negative prices and ensuring fair compensation for producers.
  • Encouraging investment in storage technologies through subsidies, tax incentives and research grants will be crucial for grid stability.
  • Investing in modern grid infrastructure, including smart grids and advanced forecasting systems, will ensure reliable integration of renewable energy sources.

India’s renewable energy targets represent a transformative step towards a sustainable energy future. By learning from Germany’s experience with solar power, India can anticipate and mitigate potential challenges. Effective grid management, economic policies and technological advancements will be essential to harness the full potential of solar and wind energy, ensuring economic growth and environmental sustainability. Through strategic planning and investment, India can achieve its renewable energy goals and set an example for other nations to follow.

Publication – Powerline

By Arindam Ghosh